Blog
Stiff vs. liquid sourdough starter: the difference, and how to switch
A stiff starter is 50 to 65% hydration, King Arthur Baking says. How it differs from a liquid one, the 1:2:1 feeding, converting, and recipe water.
Aiden Sung, MyQuietSpotUpdated 10 min read
This post contains paid links: we may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Short answer: the difference is water. A liquid starter, the kind King Arthur Baking's recipes generally call for, is equal weights of flour and water, so you stir it. A stiff starter has about half to two-thirds as much water as flour, so it's a firm dough you knead.
You don't need to keep both. King Arthur says it's "not necessary or advisable to maintain every type of starter imaginable", but that it helps to know how to convert yours when a recipe calls for the other kind. Here's how the two differ, how to switch, and how to adjust a recipe's water when you do.
The difference in one line
Hydration is the weight of the water compared with the weight of the flour, with the flour counted as 100%. A starter fed equal weights of flour and water is at 100%.
| Liquid starter | Stiff starter | |
|---|---|---|
| Hydration, per King Arthur Baking | usually 100 to 125% | usually 50 to 65% |
| Hydration, per The Perfect Loaf's stiff-starter post | 65% or more | 65% or less |
| Feeding it, per The Perfect Loaf | like stirring a thick milkshake | like kneading a dough |
| Ready to use, per King Arthur Baking | at its peak, or just as it begins to fall | doubled, domed, and just starting to sink in the middle |
The sources draw the line in different places: King Arthur's liquid range starts at 100%, while The Perfect Loaf's stiff-starter post splits the two at 65%. The Perfect Loaf's newer guide to sourness is closer to King Arthur: a stiff levain at about 50 to 65%, a liquid one at 100%. SBS Food puts stiff starters at around 50 to 60%. King Arthur's own stiff starter is 50%, twice as much flour as water by weight.
Flavor, timing and storage
Flavor: stiffness alone doesn't decide it
You'll often read that a stiff starter makes bread more sour. King Arthur Baking's 2015 post on stiff starters once suggested that a stiff starter can promote more sour flavor, and that it holds up better in the fridge. They later removed both claims, after input from the microbiologist Debra Wink.
In The Perfect Loaf's guide to making bread more or less sour, Maurizio Leo writes that lower hydration slows bacteria more than it slows yeast, shifting the balance toward acetic acid, the sharper, vinegar-like kind. He lists a stiff levain (the batch of starter you build for a dough) as one way to get more sourness, but only with enough time to ripen: stiffness alone, he says, doesn't guarantee it. His example is lievito madre, the stiff starter used for panettone, which makes very mild bread when it's fed often on a tight schedule. His earlier post on baking with a stiff starter calls the idea that it makes bread more sour a misconception.
His other levers for more tang include a starter used past its peak, a longer cold proof, warmer fermentation and more whole grain flour. So choose a stiff starter for how it handles, not as a sure route to tangier bread. In his stiff-starter post, he concludes that "the choice between the two mostly comes down to your personal preference": stirring a loose starter, or kneading a firm one.
Timing
None of the sources we read timed the two side by side. The closest is SBS Food, which says a regular loaf made with lievito madre (a sweetened stiff starter) may rise faster than one made with a wet starter. Here's what King Arthur and The Perfect Loaf report for a stiff starter:
- King Arthur's stiff starter, fed 1 part starter, 1 part water and 2 parts all-purpose flour at room temperature, takes about 8 hours to double and dome. If it has already collapsed by then, they say it will still work. If that keeps happening, use cooler water and add a pinch of salt.
- The Perfect Loaf's stiff levain, with half of its flour whole wheat and kept at 78 to 80°F (about 26 to 27°C), was ready in 4 to 5 hours.
Both sources find a stiff starter easier to time than a liquid one. King Arthur's post says its best moment "is more easily recognized", and The Perfect Loaf calls it "a little more forgiving" about feeding time, because its dome falls later.
One test may let you down: answering a reader, Maurizio Leo notes that a stiff starter might not float, and that the float test isn't definitive anyway. Watch for the dome instead.
Storage
King Arthur no longer says a stiff starter holds up better in the fridge. To keep a stiff starter you aren't baking with right away, they let it ferment for 2 hours at room temperature after a feeding, instead of 8, then refrigerate it.
After time in the fridge, both kinds benefit from a revival, King Arthur says: leave the starter at room temperature and feed it morning and night until it's good and bubbly. Our guide to storing a starter in the fridge covers the rest.
How to switch from liquid to stiff
King Arthur's method starts from the starter you'd normally discard. Their recipe gives cups and grams; these are the grams:
- First feeding. Take 227 g of liquid starter at 100% hydration and mix in 113 g of unbleached all-purpose flour, with no water. Knead until the dough is smooth and firm with no dry spots. If it feels very sticky, add a tablespoon or two more flour. It's now about 50% hydration.
- Let it ferment. Put it in an oiled container with the lid on, at room temperature, for about 8 hours.
- Second feeding. Tear the stiff starter into pieces and weigh out 57 g. Add 57 g of room-temperature water and 113 g of unbleached all-purpose flour, then knead to a firm, smooth dough with no dry pockets of flour. The rest of the first batch is discard.
- Wait for the dome. Put it in a bowl covered with plastic. After about 8 hours, it should have doubled and domed, with the center just beginning to sink. It's ready to bake with.
From then on, King Arthur feeds it 1 part starter, 1 part water and 2 parts flour by weight. In the starter : flour : water order our calculator uses, that's 1:2:1. Our free feeding calculator works out the grams for any amount: choose Custom, then enter 2 flour parts and 1 water part.
King Arthur recommends a scale for all of this, to avoid the errors that come with measuring by volume. In the app we make, Sourdough Starter Tracker, you can log a feeding with a custom ratio such as 1:2:1, and it stays on the ratio list as a one-tap choice for the next feeding. Having the app work out the grams from the ratio is a Premium feature.
We haven't tested these ourselves. They're here for two jobs: weighing and keeping a stiff starter.
Going back to liquid
King Arthur's stiff starter recipe also goes the other way: tear the stiff starter into small pieces and mix it with lukewarm water, 3 parts starter to 1 part water by weight or volume, such as 6 ounces (170 g) of stiff starter with 2 ounces (57 g) of water. That brings a 50% starter back to equal parts flour and water. They say the easiest way to mix it is a stand mixer on low speed, with the beater attachment.
Using one in a recipe written for the other
Swap in the other kind at the same weight and the dough comes out drier or wetter than the recipe intended. The fix is to keep the dough's total flour and water the same.
Stiff starter (50%) in a recipe for liquid starter (100%). For every 100 g of liquid starter in the recipe, use 75 g of stiff starter and add 25 g more water to the dough. That's King Arthur's 3-to-1 conversion, done in the mixing bowl. A recipe that calls for 200 g of starter gets 150 g of stiff starter and 50 g of extra water.
Why it works: 75 g of a 50% starter holds 50 g of flour and 25 g of water. Add 25 g of water and you have the 50 g of flour and 50 g of water in 100 g of liquid starter.
Liquid starter (100%) in a recipe for stiff starter (50%). For every 100 g of stiff starter in the recipe, use 133 g of liquid starter and leave out 33 g of the recipe's water.
Any other hydration. Our free dough hydration calculator counts the flour and water inside a starter at any hydration. Enter the recipe as written under "Check my recipe" to see its real hydration. Then switch to "Hit a hydration", enter that number with the weight and hydration of the starter you'll actually use, and it tells you how much water to add. To keep the dough's total flour and water the same too, use enough of your starter to supply as much flour as the recipe's starter does.
Mixing it in. The Perfect Loaf notes that a stiff starter is a little harder to mix into a dough. King Arthur's stiff-starter bread recipe tears the starter into small pieces and adds them to the recipe's water before the flour goes in.
This keeps the dough as written, not the starter's behavior, so the recipe's timings may not match exactly.
Italian names: lievito madre, pasta madre, licoli
- Lievito madre (also pasta madre or pasta acida) is the general Italian name for a sourdough starter. Altroconsumo, an Italian consumer association, says it comes as lievito madre liquido or lievito madre solido, depending on how much water goes in with the flour.
- Licoli is the liquid kind. RSI, the Italian-language Swiss public broadcaster, explains the name as an acronym of lievito, coltura and liquida (yeast, culture, liquid). It puts licoli at 100% hydration and the solid kind at 50% (100 g of flour to 50 g of water). RSI also calls the liquid form the easiest for a first try, since a whisk is enough to feed it, while it says the solid kind needs a mixer. (King Arthur, for its stiff starter, says kneading by hand is easy.)
- Rinfresco (plural rinfreschi) means a refreshment, which is what Italian sources call a feeding: adding new flour and water to feed the microbes in it.
In English, the sources we read use lievito madre for the stiff kind: SBS Food calls it a firm sourdough starter, and The Perfect Loaf calls it the stiff starter used in panettone. SBS adds that what sets lievito madre apart from other stiff starters is a sweetener, either sugar or honey in its feedings or an occasional soak in sugar water, a step SBS calls washing.
Sources disagree on flavor here too. RSI describes the solid kind as stronger tasting and leaning sour, and licoli as more neutral and delicate. SBS, writing about the sweetened kind, describes lievito madre as mild, with no sour taste.
Sources
- King Arthur Baking: Artisan sourdough bread tips, part 1: Creating and using a stiff starter, Stiff Sourdough Starter, How to store sourdough starter
- The Perfect Loaf: Baking Sourdough Bread with a Stiff Starter, How To Make Sourdough Bread More (Or Less) Sour
- Altroconsumo: Lievito madre: cos'è, come usarlo e conservarlo al meglio (Italian)
- RSI: Tutto sul lievito madre, o meglio "pasta madre" (Italian)
- SBS Food: This is pasta madre, and it's not pasta at all
- WECK: 743 ¾ L Mold Jar
FAQ
What is a stiff sourdough starter?
A starter made with much less water than flour, so it's a firm dough you knead rather than a batter you stir. King Arthur Baking says stiff starters are generally 50 to 65% hydration (the water's weight compared with the flour's), and theirs is 50%: twice as much flour as water. Their usual liquid starter is equal parts flour and water, or 100%.
Does a stiff starter make bread more sour?
Not on its own. King Arthur Baking removed an earlier claim that a stiff starter promotes more sour flavor. The Perfect Loaf lists a stiff levain as one way to get more sourness, but says stiffness alone doesn't guarantee it: ripening time, temperature and flour matter too. Sources on the Italian starters differ too: RSI says the solid kind leans sour, while SBS Food, writing about the sweetened lievito madre, calls it mild.
How do I convert a liquid starter to a stiff starter?
King Arthur Baking mixes 227 g of 100% hydration starter with 113 g of unbleached all-purpose flour and no water, and lets it ferment for about 8 hours. From then on they feed it 1 part starter, 1 part water and 2 parts flour by weight, which is 1:2:1 in starter : flour : water order.
Can I use a stiff starter in a recipe that calls for a liquid starter?
Yes, if you add back the missing water. For every 100 g of 100% starter in the recipe, use 75 g of 50% stiff starter and add 25 g more water to the dough. That's the same 3-to-1 mix of stiff starter and water that King Arthur Baking uses to turn a stiff starter back into a liquid one.