Blog

The best flour for a sourdough starter, to start it and to feed it

Which flour to use for a new sourdough starter, which to feed it every day, when rye or whole wheat helps, whether bread flour is worth it, and flour names in other countries.

Aiden Sung, MyQuietSpotUpdated 4 min read

This post contains paid links: we may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Short answer: start a new starter with whole grain flour, such as whole wheat or rye, then feed it all-purpose flour. That's what King Arthur Baking does in its own starter recipe. A little whole grain flour in a feeding or two can wake up a sluggish starter. Here's what each flour does, with the source for each point.

To start a new starter: whole wheat or rye

King Arthur Baking likes to begin a starter with whole grain flour: whole wheat, or pumpernickel (coarse whole rye). Their reason is that the wild yeast that gives a starter its life "is more likely to be found" in whole grain flour than in all-purpose flour. They say the same is true for rye.

You don't have to keep feeding it whole grain. In King Arthur's starter recipe, only the first mix is whole grain. Every feeding after that uses unbleached all-purpose flour.

To feed it every day: all-purpose

King Arthur calls all-purpose flour "a great choice to feed your sourdough starter", and says it's what most bakers use. Their own starter recipe calls for it (unbleached all-purpose). Regular feedings with it keep a starter healthy, they say, so you can settle into an easy routine.

Bread flour works too, but you don't need it. Its higher protein builds stronger gluten for bread dough, and King Arthur explains that a starter doesn't necessarily need that. King Arthur says it "won't make much of a difference either way."

Whole wheat as the everyday flour is fine if you prefer it. King Arthur notes that some bakers keep an all-whole-wheat starter, for the flavor or because they bake a lot of whole wheat bread. You don't need one for whole wheat bread, though: the flour in the starter is only a small part of the recipe's flour.

A little whole grain for a sluggish starter

If your starter has gone slow, King Arthur suggests adding some whole wheat flour to one or two feedings. The nutrients and minerals in whole wheat flour "can accelerate fermentation of both the bacteria and the yeast," they explain, which can get a starter ready to use more quickly.

Rye works the same way. King Arthur recommends about 10 to 20% rye in proportion to the white flour, and notes that this small amount won't affect the starter's flavor, so you can still use it in any recipe that calls for a regular starter.

If it's still slow after that, our guide to why a starter isn't rising goes through the other usual causes, such as a cold kitchen.

Changing flours

King Arthur describes keeping a regular all-purpose starter and feeding it whole wheat now and then. After a whole grain feeding, the starter may be ready sooner than usual, so watch it rather than the clock.

Keeping a note of what you fed helps you see what a change did. In the app we make, Sourdough Starter Tracker, each feeding can record your main flour and any flour you mixed in. A notebook or our free printable feeding log works too.

What about gluten-free flour?

Only for a gluten-free starter. King Arthur doesn't recommend feeding gluten-free flour to a regular starter, and has separate recipes for gluten-free starters.

Flour names in other countries

Flour grades don't map exactly between countries. This table follows Wikipedia's comparison, which lines up wheat grades by ash (mineral) content, a measure of how much of the whole grain is in the flour. Protein and baking strength still vary by brand, and German Wikipedia describes Type 550 as a strong all-round flour that's also used for white bread.

US UK Germany France Italy
All-purpose Plain Type 550 T55 Tipo 0
Bread flour Strong Type 812 T80 Tipo 1
Whole wheat Wholemeal Weizenvollkornmehl T150 (intégrale) Farina integrale
Whole rye Wholemeal rye Roggenvollkornmehl Seigle T170 (intégrale) Segale integrale

Sources

FAQ

What's the best flour to start a sourdough starter?

Whole grain flour, such as whole wheat or rye. King Arthur Baking recommends it for creating a new starter, because the wild yeast that gives a starter its life is more likely to be found in whole grain flour than in all-purpose flour.

Can I feed my starter all-purpose flour?

Yes. King Arthur Baking calls all-purpose flour a great choice for feeding a starter and says it's what most bakers use. It's also the flour their own starter recipe uses after the first day.

Is bread flour better for a sourdough starter?

Not really. King Arthur Baking says you don't need it, and that it won't make much of a difference either way. Use it if it's what you have.

How do I give a sluggish starter a boost?

King Arthur Baking suggests adding some whole wheat flour to one or two feedings, or rye at about 10 to 20% of the white flour. They say that small amount of rye won't affect the starter's flavor.

Related

← All blog