Blog
The sourdough starter float test: what it tells you and what it doesn't
Only partly: a starter can float before it's ready, and some ripe ones sink. How to do the float test, and the rise check to use instead, source by source.
Aiden Sung, MyQuietSpotUpdated 9 min read
This post contains paid links: we may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Short answer: if a spoonful of fed starter floats, it has trapped plenty of gas, but that doesn't prove it's ready to bake with. In a test on King Arthur Baking's blog, a starter floated while the baker judged it still hours from ripe, and The Perfect Loaf finds that some ripe starters rarely float at all. Whether the starter has doubled in its jar tells you more. Here's how to do the float test, what it can and can't tell you, and where the sources disagree.
How to do the float test
- Feed your starter as usual and let it rise.
- Drop a small spoonful into a bowl of water. South Dakota State University Extension specifies room-temperature water; the other guides just say water.
- See whether it floats or sinks.
The idea, as King Arthur Baking's float test post explains it: as the yeast in a starter works, it makes tiny bubbles of carbon dioxide. The gas is trapped in the gluten formed by the flour and water, which makes the starter rise and lightens it. Trap enough gas, and a spoonful floats, the same way fully risen yeast dough does.
Before or after feeding? After, while the starter rises. Clemson's guide gives the float test as a quick tip right after describing a starter at its peak height after feeding. King Arthur's post tested a fed starter, and a spoonful taken right after feeding sank.
What it can tell you, and what it can't
A float doesn't prove it's ready
In a 2019 post on King Arthur Baking's blog, PJ Hamel fed a starter that had been in the fridge, unfed, for several weeks. A spoonful sank right after feeding. Four hours later, the starter had only a few small bubbles, and Hamel estimated it had at least 2 to 4 hours to go before it would be ready for baking. Yet a spoonful floated.
That's one baker's test. The post asks whether the float test is a good way to judge a starter's baking readiness, and answers: "No." Its conclusion: a growing but not yet ripe starter will float.
Maurizio Leo of The Perfect Loaf sees the same problem. He calls the float test a good general sign that a starter has fermented significantly, but finds it isn't 100% reliable for telling when a starter is ready, and that it can give false positives.
A sink doesn't prove it isn't ready
King Arthur's post says that if a fed starter sinks, it's definitely not ready for the next step in your recipe.
The Perfect Loaf sees exceptions. Leo finds that when a starter isn't mostly white flour at a moderate to high hydration, it will rarely float, even when it's ripe. That includes, for example, a starter fed mostly whole wheat or rye, or a stiff, low-hydration one.
America's Test Kitchen says the float test isn't accurate for gluten-free starters. They don't trap gas the way a starter with gluten does, they're denser, and with nothing to hold them together, they dissolve in water.
Where the sources disagree
Extension guides from Clemson and South Dakota State present a float as a sign of readiness: if a small spoonful floats, the starter is ready to use. America's Test Kitchen's guide to gluten-free starters also calls a float an indication that a starter is at its peak, before explaining why that doesn't hold for gluten-free starters. The King Arthur blog test and The Perfect Loaf say a float on its own isn't enough. Taken the way that King Arthur post frames it, the test only works in one direction: a sink says wait, a float says maybe. And for the kind of starter The Perfect Loaf says rarely floats, or a gluten-free one, even a sink doesn't tell you much.
A better test: has it doubled?
The same King Arthur post ends with the signs of a ripe starter: it's very bubbly, and it reliably doubles in size within 6 to 8 hours of feeding. Here's how to watch for that.
- Use a clear container. King Arthur's guide to creating a starter says it's useful to feed a starter in a clear, straight-sided container, so it's easy to track its rise.
- Mark the level right after feeding. King Arthur's sourdough booklet suggests a rubber band around the jar or an erasable marker.
- Note the time. The booklet says a starter fed 1:1:1 (equal weights of starter, flour and water) usually reaches peak ripeness about 6 to 8 hours after feeding, though it can take more or less time depending on how warm your kitchen is and how healthy the starter is. Bigger feeding ratios take longer: a feeding-ratio post on King Arthur's blog says the more flour and water you add in proportion to the starter, the slower it rises.
- Look for the double, then the slowdown. King Arthur's 2016 post on ripe starter defines it as one that was recently fed, doubled or tripled in volume, and then slowed down in activity. In that post's photos, a starter 8 hours after feeding had doubled and was just beginning to sag under its own weight.
Sources differ on the timing. Clemson's guide expects an established starter to double within 4 to 6 hours of feeding. That feeding-ratio post, by contributor Hannah Dela Cruz, says a healthy mature starter fed 1:1:1 at about 78°F (26°C) usually peaks after about 4 to 6 hours, anywhere from 4 to 8 depending on the starter and the kitchen. King Arthur's booklet, starter guide and float test post give 6 to 8 hours. As the ratio post notes, every starter is different, so timing your own tells you more than any single number.
Our free peak time calculator gives a starting estimate for 1:1:1, 1:2:2 and 1:4:4 feedings, based on the timings in that feeding-ratio post, at about 78°F (26°C); above 1:4:4 it doesn't give a number. If you're not sure what you're looking at, our ready-to-bake check asks six quick questions: warning signs, how much it has risen, how long since you fed it, the feeding ratio, how warm it is, and whether it doubled the time before too.
We haven't tested this jar ourselves. We picked it because it's clear glass with a wide opening.
If it never doubles, our guide to a sourdough starter that isn't rising goes through the usual causes. For more on jars, see how to choose a jar for a sourdough starter.
If it floated before and sinks now
Look at the jar before you decide anything.
- It may have peaked and fallen. King Arthur says starters fall after they peak, and once they start to fall, they no longer look doubled. Fresh residue on the side of the container is the evidence it did double. A starter that has doubled or tripled and then started to sink again is what King Arthur calls over-ripe. None of the sources we used tested a starter in water after its peak, so we can't tell you how a fallen starter does in the float test.
- Just starting to fall is fine. A King Arthur post on artisan sourdough says the time to add a fed liquid starter to a recipe is at its peak of rising, or just as it's beginning to fall. In a feeding-ratio trial on King Arthur's blog, contributor Hannah Dela Cruz's 1:1:1 starter was beginning to fall at 8 hours and could still be used for baking.
- Well past its peak? In the same trial, by 12 hours that starter had dropped a lot in volume, and Dela Cruz called it ready to be fed. Feed it, and note how long the next rise takes to reach its high point.
- Did you change the flour or the water? If you've switched to mostly whole grain flour or a stiff, low-hydration feed, The Perfect Loaf's point applies: such a starter may not float, even when it's ripe.
And if a spoonful floats for a moment and then drops in the bowl, none of our sources says what that means. Go by the rise in the jar.
Summary
- Do the float test after a feeding, with a small spoonful in water.
- If it sinks: King Arthur's float test post says a fed starter that sinks isn't ready. But a ripe starter that isn't mostly white flour at a moderate to high hydration will rarely float (The Perfect Loaf), and the test isn't accurate for gluten-free starters (America's Test Kitchen).
- If it floats: it has trapped gas, but it may not be ripe yet. Clemson and South Dakota State extensions treat a float as ready, and America's Test Kitchen calls it an indication of peak, though not for gluten-free starters; King Arthur's blog test and The Perfect Loaf say it isn't enough on its own.
- The better sign: a very bubbly starter that reliably doubles after feeding. King Arthur's booklet says a 1:1:1 feeding peaks in about 6 to 8 hours; Clemson says an established starter doubles within 4 to 6 hours, and a feeding-ratio post on King Arthur's blog says a 1:1:1 feeding at about 78°F (26°C) usually peaks in 4 to 6 hours (anywhere from 4 to 8).
- Mark the jar and note the time at each feeding, and you'll learn how long your starter takes. The app we make, Sourdough Starter Tracker, shows when a starter on the counter should peak after each feeding, starting from the timings in the feeding-ratio post on King Arthur's blog. When you see it peak, you tap "It's peaking now", and the app uses your checks to adjust that starter's timing.
If you keep your starter in the fridge, see how often to feed a sourdough starter for how to wake it up before you bake.
Sources
- King Arthur Baking: The float test for yeast dough and sourdough starter, Ripe sourdough starter: Here's what that means, Sourdough Tips & Recipes booklet, Sourdough Baking guide: Create, Baking trials: Testing different sourdough feeding ratios, Artisan sourdough bread tips, part 1, How to store sourdough starter
- The Perfect Loaf: Frequently Asked Sourdough Starter Questions
- America's Test Kitchen: Troubleshooting Your Gluten-Free Sourdough Starter
- Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home & Garden Information Center: How to Make, Feed, and Bake With a Sourdough Starter: Sourdough 101 Guide
- South Dakota State University Extension: Sourdough Starters
- WECK: 743 ¾ L Mold Jar
FAQ
Does the float test work for sourdough starter?
Only partly. In a test on King Arthur Baking's blog, one baker's starter floated 4 hours after feeding, though by the baker's own estimate it still had at least 2 to 4 hours to go before it was ready to bake with. The Perfect Loaf's Maurizio Leo also finds the test can give false positives. Extension guides from Clemson and South Dakota State, on the other hand, treat a floating spoonful as a sign the starter is ready, and America's Test Kitchen calls a float an indication that a starter is at its peak, though not for gluten-free starters.
My starter sinks. Does that mean it isn't ready?
Not necessarily. King Arthur Baking's float test post says a fed starter that sinks isn't ready for the next step. But The Perfect Loaf's Maurizio Leo finds that a starter that isn't mostly white flour at a moderate to high hydration will rarely float, even when it's ripe, and America's Test Kitchen says the test isn't accurate for gluten-free starters. Check whether it has doubled in the jar.
Should I do the float test before or after feeding?
After a feeding, while the starter rises. In the King Arthur blog test, a starter that had sat unfed in the fridge for several weeks sank right after it was fed. Four hours later a spoonful floated, though the baker estimated it still had at least 2 to 4 hours to go.
What's a better way to tell if my starter is ready?
Watch it rise. King Arthur Baking says a ripe starter is very bubbly and reliably doubles in size within 6 to 8 hours of feeding. Mark the level with a rubber band or an erasable marker right after you feed it, so you can see when it has doubled.