Blog

How to choose a jar for a sourdough starter: size, shape and lid

What makes a good sourdough starter jar, based on King Arthur Baking's advice: how big, what shape, glass or plastic, and why the lid shouldn't be airtight. Plus the jars we'd buy.

Aiden Sung, MyQuietSpotUpdated 4 min read

This post contains paid links: we may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

A starter isn't fussy about where it lives, but you'll stir, scrape, mark and wash its jar often, so a good one makes the routine easier. Here's what King Arthur Baking advises, and the jars we'd pick.

We haven't tested these ourselves. We chose them to match that advice (a clear jar, a wide opening, room to grow, a lid you can leave unsealed) from what's sold on Amazon.

Size: room to triple

King Arthur Baking's sourdough booklet says any non-reactive, ½- to 1-quart lidded container will do (about 0.5 to 1 liter). For making a new starter from scratch, their guide recommends at least 1 quart.

Plan for the rise. A ripe starter doubles after a feeding, sometimes triples, so King Arthur suggests a container large enough to hold triple the starter's volume. Size the jar for what's in it right after a feeding, not for what you keep between feedings. In King Arthur's feeding method, for example, you keep 50 g of starter and add 50 g each of flour and water, so 150 g of starter goes back into the jar each time.

Shape: straight sides, wide mouth

Straight sides. King Arthur says it's useful to feed a starter in a clear, straight-sided container, so you can easily track its rise. In a straight-sided jar, the starter has doubled when it reaches twice its starting height.

A wide mouth. King Arthur also suggests a container with a wide opening, so you can stir the starter right in it.

Lid: covered, but not sealed

King Arthur's advice is that the lid should fit securely, to avoid spills and keep the starter clean, but it shouldn't be airtight: a starter gives off gas that can build up and cause a messy blowout. The crocks they sell have "loose-fitting lids to allow gasses to escape".

  • A loose lid that sits on top works well.
  • A screw lid works if you don't tighten it all the way.
  • On a clamp jar like WECK, leave the clips off so the glass lid just rests on its rubber ring.

The fridge is the exception. King Arthur suggests capping the jar tightly once a refrigerated starter has stopped bubbling, to slow evaporation.

Glass or plastic

King Arthur says glass, crockery, stainless steel and food-grade plastic all work fine, as long as the container is non-reactive. Their booklet adds that clear containers are convenient, because you can see the starter's activity as it ripens.

  • Glass lets you watch the rise from the side and is easy to scrub. It can break if you drop it.
  • Clear plastic containers also let you see the rise, and they won't shatter.
  • Ceramic crocks are, in King Arthur's words, "a beautiful and traditional choice", but you can't see the rise through the side, so you'll lift the lid to check.

Do you need to wash it every time?

No. In King Arthur's feeding method, you put the starter back into the same container, and they note "there's no need to clean it". If dry, crusty starter builds up on the walls, move the starter to a clean jar. Our guide to telling mold from harmless look-alikes shows what's dried starter and what isn't.

For the fridge

In King Arthur's method, a starter kept in the fridge is fed about once a week. If your recipes call for only a little starter, you can keep a smaller one, which King Arthur notes means much less discard. They make a 1-quart Petite crock for smaller starters, though its opening is only about 3 inches (7.6 cm) wide. Our guide to storing a starter in the fridge covers how to keep it happy between bakes.

Mark the rise

King Arthur's booklet suggests a rubber band or an erasable marker on the jar to mark the starter's level and track its growth. If you note the time as well, you'll see how long your starter takes to peak. Our free peak time calculator gives you a starting estimate. The app we make, Sourdough Starter Tracker, learns your starter's timing from your checks: when you look at the jar, you tell it whether the starter is still rising, at its peak or already falling.

Sources

FAQ

What size jar do I need for a sourdough starter?

King Arthur Baking's sourdough booklet says any non-reactive ½- to 1-quart (about 0.5 to 1 liter) lidded container will do, and their guide to making a new starter recommends at least 1 quart. Either way, the jar should hold about triple the starter's volume, because a ripe starter can double or triple after a feeding.

Should a sourdough starter jar be airtight?

Not while it's active. King Arthur Baking says the lid shouldn't be airtight, because a starter gives off gas that can build up and cause a messy blowout. In the fridge, once the starter has stopped bubbling, they suggest capping it tightly to slow evaporation.

Glass or plastic for a sourdough starter?

Either works. King Arthur Baking says glass, crockery, stainless steel and food-grade plastic all work fine, and that a clear container is convenient because you can watch the starter rise.

Related

← All blog